Here you find out which ones do, and how far. We take nutrition myths one by one: where the evidence ends and the extrapolation begins.
articles reviewed
myths with a closed verdict
How it works
From article or myth to answer, in three steps
01You bring the article or the claimSearch for the article in our base, pick a myth from the list, or bring the claim you heard.
02We apply the international yardstick the study design calls forWe measure risk of bias domain by domain and the strength of the evidence, with the same rigor for what’s for and for what’s against.
03You get the appraisal of the article and of the mythThe methodological assessment in an appraisal that explains each step, and the myth’s answer in a card with the strength of the evidence and the studies behind it.
A real example
Before trusting the method, read what we have already published
Two pieces open to everyone, one click away: an article appraised in full and a myth with a closed verdict.
The reliability badge
How much a study's result can be trusted
Every appraisal receives its own badge, from a methodology that is ours: it brings the recognised critical-appraisal tools into a single judgement — the study design, the quality of its conduct and how well it applies to practice.
Does the study's result reflect reality?
Highvery likely
Moderatelikely, with caveats
Limitedmay be quite different
Fragilevery uncertain
What we strengthen
Evidence is one of the three legs of the decision
A good health decision rests on three pillars:
Scientific evidence — the best and most current research on what works and what doesn’t. This is where we work.
Clinical expertise — the professional’s knowledge, experience and technical judgment.
Patient values — each person’s life context, needs and choices.
The tool gives clinical work a foundation, it does not replace it.
Why we exist
Evidence, not spin
In Brazil, much of the information about nutrition and health is sold as certainty: the diet that works, the protocol, the supplement. What was missing was a place that showed, in plain language and without rooting for any side, what good evidence actually says. That is what this project tries to be.
Who does the appraisals
The judgement is human; the tooling speeds it up
The critical reading of each study follows the best methods available, applied article by article. Automation organises and speeds up the work around it, but what each study proves goes through a person's scrutiny.
Validated yardsticks, applied case by caseRoB 2, AMSTAR 2, GRADE and others applied to the article, not merely cited.
Human check before publishingNo appraisal enters the base without a person reading it.
Retroactive review when the method changesA new criterion sends already published appraisals back to the table.
We don’t sell a dietWe don’t root for low-carb, for veganism, for fasting or for any banner: symmetrical skepticism.
What does good evidence actually say?
Filter or search for the claim you have heard around, and open the card to see the answer.
Detailed analyses are shown in Portuguese.
Understand how reliable a study is
Detailed analyses are shown in Portuguese.
Already have the DOI or PMID?iThe DOI is the article’s unique code (e.g. 10.1056/NEJMoa2032183). It is usually on the first page of the PDF or on the article’s page on the journal site. The PMID is the equivalent number in PubMed.
Or search by the article title
A sample open to everyone. The plan opens the whole collection.
Detailed analyses are shown in Portuguese.
Learn to read a scientific paper
The essentials for understanding study designs, statistics, biases and the strength of evidence.
The mini-course is shown in Portuguese.
Painel do projeto
Onde o projeto está agora, e o que pede atenção.
What the subscription opens
Every appraisal in the base, every verdict with the studies behind each answer, and search across the collection by DOI, PMID or title.
Two ways to subscribe
Monthly or yearly, with the same access. On the yearly plan, the price per month is lower.
Monthly
Billed month to month
Cancel whenever you want
Yearly
12 months up front
What changes between visitor, free account and subscription.
Feature
Visitor
With a free account
Subscriber
Full appraisal of each article
Not included
Not included
Yes
Search the collection by DOI, PMID or title
Not included
Not included
Yes
Article appraisal on request*
Not included
Not included
Critical appraisal mini-course (free with an account)
First module
All modules
All modules
Single appraisal
The same appraisal for everyone
The appraisal is the same for everyone: the badge, the certainty and the limitation you read for free are exactly the subscriber's. What changes is how much you read.
Request a critical appraisal
Talk to us
Subscribe
Enter the email that will receive access. You then go to Mercado Pago and choose how to pay there.
The account is only created once the payment is approved — and access goes to this address.
Sign in
No password: you type your email and we send you a link that signs you in.
Signing in opens your session, not the plan's archive: if you have not subscribed yet, you sign in and keep seeing what is already open to everyone. Subscribers sign in here and the collection opens.